Open Access
Subscription or Fee Access
Economic Sustainability of Transportation Infrastructure Procurement: The Differing Site Condition Clause Debate as an Underlying Environmental Trigger to Cost Overruns
Abstract
Case law is rife with contractual disputes arising due to lack of adequate geotechnical risk containment during procurement. The use of a ‘Differing Site Conditions (DSC) clause’, implies that, in the event of encountering a subsurface/geo-environmental condition different from that which was indicated in the contract, the owner bears the additional cost for executing the work under such conditions. However, the literature indicates a divergence in industry practise, with some clients opting to allocate the liability for geotechnical risk to the contractor by incorporating exculpatory clauses in contracts. This study evaluates the dynamics of risk aversion by clients and contractors as a pervasive culture of most infrastructure projects, and how the strategic behaviour of both parties to a contract has important implications for the accuracy of the client’s final outturn cost. The study thus outlines the contractual consequences of lack of geotechnical risk containment, by weighing the arguments posed in the literature. The study findings support the view that adequate geotechnical characterisation of projects prior to contract award via the inclusion of ground investigation reports, with a further provision for DSC clause, is a key investment strategy for the sustainable procurement of road projects, necessary to avert the risk of variations and claims leading to delays and cost overruns.
Keywords:Cost overruns, geotechnical risk, procurement, risk management, transportation infrastructure
Cite this Article
AloloteIbimAmadi, Amadi Kelvin Chijioke.Economic Sustainability of Transportation Infrastructure Procurement: The Differing Site Condition ClauseDebate as an Underlying Environmental Trigger to Cost Overruns.Journal of Construction Engineering, Technology & Management. 2020; 10(1): 11–19p.
Keywords
References
Asmar ME, Hanna AS, Whited GC. New approach to developing conceptual cost estimates for highway projects. Journal of construction engineering and management. 2011 Nov 1;137(11):942–9.
Chan EH, Au MC. Building contractors’ behavioral pattern in pricing weather risks. International Journal of Project Management. 2007 Aug 1;25(6):615–26.
Chan APC and Yeong CM. (1995). A comparison of strategies for reducing variations.Construction Management and Economics, 13 (6), 467–473.
Chou J. (2005). Item-level quantity-based preliminary cost estimating system for highway earthwork, landscape, subgrade treatments, base, surface courses, pavement and traffic control. Doctoral dissertation presented to the faculty of the graduate school of the University of Texas at Austin.https://repositories.lib.utexas.
edu/handle/2152/1845
Clayton CRI. (2001). Managing geotechnical risk: Time for a Change. Proceedings ICE. Geotechnical Engineering. Paper 149(1). 3–11 Thomas Telford.
Crowley L and Hancher D. (1995). Risk assessment of competitive procurement. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management. 121, 241–248.
DRMB, 2006; Design Manual for Roads and Bridges. (2008.) Managing geotechnical risk. Volume 4 section 1 Part 2 HD 22/08 http://www.standardsforhigh
ways.co.uk/ha/standards/Ghost/dmrb/vol4/section1/hd2208.pdf
Engineers’ Joint Contract Documents Committee (2016) contracts. https://www.
ejcdc.org/
FIDIC Yellow Book (1999) Mechanical and Electrical Building and Engineering Works designed by the Employer. International Federation of Consulting Engineers,https://fidic.org/sites/default
t/files/FIDIC_Suite_of_Contracts_0.pdf
FIDIC Red Book (1999). Building and Engineering Works designed by the Contractor. International Federation of Consulting Engineers
Federal Acquisition Regulation. (2005). Solicitation Provisions and Contract Clauses. FAC 2005–89–1. Part 52 [online]. Available at
gov/?q=browse/far/52> accessed24/02/
Geddes S. (1985). Estimating for Building and Civil Engineering Works, 8ed, London: Butterworth
Georgia Dept. of Transportation. (2007). Planning level cost estimation study. 〈http://www.dot.ga.gov/informationcenter/programs/studies/Pages/CostEstimationStudy.aspx
Groove Report (1998). Consultant's Report on Review of General Conditions of Contract for Construction Works, The Government of the Hong Kong SAR
Halwatura RU. and. Ranasinghe NPNP. (2013). Causes of Variation Orders in Road Construction Projects in Sri Lanka. International Scholarly Research Notices. Dec 5;2013; pp 36–42.
Harrison S. (1981) Estimating and tendering–some aspects of theory and practice, Estimating information service, The Chartered Institute of Building, ISSN 0308 8073, No.41. 1981
Institution of Civil Engineers (1999) Institution of Civil Engineers Standard Form of Engineering Contract, 7th Edition.
Kartam NA and Kartam SA. (2001). Risk and its management in the Kuwaiti construction industry: a contractor’s perspective, International Journal of Project Management. 19(6): 325–335.
Latham M. (1994). Constructing the Team. Final Report of the Government/ Industry Review of Procurement and Contractual Arrangement in the UK Construction Industry. HMSO Publications, July. http://www.trentglobal.
edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Lath
am-Report-1994-Constructing-the-Team.
Molenaar KR. Guide to risk assessment and allocation for highway construction management. Federal Highway Administration; 2006.
National Economic Development Office. (1988). Faster building for commerce. NEDO, London, https://www.designing
buildings.co.uk/wiki/National_Economic_Development_Office_(NEDO)_reports
National Highway Cooperative Research Program. (2004). Procedures for cost estimation and management for highway projects during planning, programming, and preconstruction. http://www.trb.org/
Main/Blurbs/158464.aspx
O’Toole D. (2006). Differing Site conditions—who bears the risk? Technical Report retrieved from https://www.
troutman.com/images/content/1/5/v1/150205/DifferingSiteConditions.pdf.
Peacock WS, Whyte IL, CASPAR, MIRA. Site investigation and risk analysis. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Civil Engineering 1992 May (Vol. 92, No. 2, pp. 74–81). Thomas Telford-ICE Virtual Library.
Perera B, Dhanasinghe I and Rameezdeen R. (2009). Risk management in road construction: The case of Sri Lanka. International Journal of Strategic Property Management. 13(2):87–102.
Rao M, Ranade HV. Risk based cost estimation of capital-intensive road projects using Monte-Carlo simulation. In International Public Works Conference 2013 Aug. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.
org/e543/5a6d3316084af4617639f1f14cac322f2866.pdf
Romero VS and JM Stolz, (2009). Cost Estimating for Underground Transit: Too Dangerous to “Guesstimate”. San Francisco, CA https://trid.trb.org/view/
Sodikov J. (2005). Cost estimation of highway projects in developing countries: artificial neural network approach. Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, 6, 1036—1047. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/bb7d/b3a54de8099677bdac33b871d64e27dbf1c4.pdf
Tah JHM, Thorpe A and McCaffer R. (1994). A survey of indirect cost estimating in practice. Construction Management and Economics.12(31):31–36.
Thompson PA. and Perry, J.G. (1992). Engineering Construction Risks. Thomas Telford, London.
Venmans AA, Forster U, Hooimeijer, R. H. Integral design of motorways on soft soil on the basis of whole life costs. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Soil Mechanics And Geotechnical Engineering 2005 (Vol. 16, No. 4, p. 2867).
Whitman RV. (2000). “Evaluating calculated risk in geotechnical engineering”, ASCE, 110, No 2, Feb, pp145–188
Wong J. (2010). What lies Beneath? An Over View of Claims relating to unforeseen Ground Conditions. Institute of Civil Engineers. https://www.hkis.org.hk
/hkis/general/events/cpd-2010047.pdf
Wong JTY and Hui ECM. (2006) Construction project risks: further considerations for constructors‟ pricing in Hong Kong. Construction Management and Engineering, 24, 425–438. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01446190600601602
Wu SC, Jin AB and Wang JN. (2005). Numerical Simulation of Stability Assessment. And design making of a subgrade retaining wall on slope. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering.24:5382–5388.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.